Serving Clients Throughout Wisconsin & Illinois 



Why the Secure Act May Make Your Retirement Less Secure

Congress can’t wait to get its hands on America’s retirement account assets, says The Wall Street Journal in the article “Congress is Coming for Your IRA.” In May, the House passed the Setting Every Community Up for Retirement Enhancement Act, known as the Secure Act, and it’s widely expected to pass the Senate. While its name sounds like it’s looking to help Americans with retirement, some believe that the bill will reduce the value of all retirement savings plans, from IRAs to 401(k)s and Roth IRA.

The problem with the Secure Act is that it eliminates the ability to stretch the IRA, which has been the gold star in the retirement sky since 1999. The stretch IRA allows account owners to leave their retirement accounts to children, grandchildren or other beneficiaries.

Under current rules, those recipients can take only Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) over the course of their actuarial lifetimes. That means small payouts, small taxes, and stretching the IRA over an extended period. Over time, the IRAs can grow through the power of tax-deferred compounding.

A parent could die knowing that whatever their children may experience in their lives, they won’t have to worry about their retirement because of the inherited IRA.

Congress wants to change this option. The Secure Act gives non-spouse beneficiaries only ten years to pull out every dime from an IRA. The net effect would be to make more of the IRA subject to higher taxes sooner, as distributions are made in bigger amounts.

Here’s the bottom line: as much as thirty percent more of an IRA will be subject to higher taxes under the Secure Act than under the current rules.

When the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act expires in 2025, taxes will rise across the board.

As part of the Secure Act, Congress will push back the age at which retirees must take their first RMD from 70 ½ to 72.

This is probably not the deal that Americans had in mind when they started saving money in IRAs some two decades ago. The best approach for savers was to leave their IRAs to the kids or the grandkids and stretch those payouts over decades.

Under the Secure Act, the IRA owner may still leave the account to a surviving spouse, who’d remain exempt from the ten-year time period. But the surviving spouse is still paying taxes in a higher tax bracket as a “filing single” taxpayer. That bracket takes a giant leap from 12% to 25% or 24% to 35% as the mandatory payout ratios increase with age.

For example, a 70-year-old is 3.7% of the retirement account balance. For a 90-year-old, it is 8.8%.

If a $1 million IRA passes to a high-earning adult, they would have to take payouts annually, adding $100,000 of annual income on top of their salary for a decade. Live in a high-income state tax, and half the annual payout could be consumed by taxes.

For those with college aged kids, watch out. Parents of college age children who inherit IRAs could lose financial aid options. If they decide to postpone taking distributions for four years to avoid the impact on needs-based financial aid, they’ll have to double up on distributions after college to compensate.

In the past, an IRA owner might have established a trust for young beneficiaries. Under the Secure Act, an IRA of $1 million placed in trust for the benefit of an 8-year-old could receive nothing for nine years. Then, at year ten, the entire IRA would have to be paid out. Now the beneficiary turns 18 and he gets a windfall. With a decade of additional compounding growth, the original IRA could have grown to $2 million or more. If it’s delivered all at once, it’s taxed in the highest bracket.

The bill hasn’t become law yet, but it’s likely that it will. If it does, make an appointment with our estate planning attorneys as soon as you can, because your carefully created estate plan may be turned upside down and sideways. To request a consultation, submit our online form.

ReferenceThe Wall Street Journal (July 9, 2019) “Congress is Coming for Your IRA”
Categories

Quality Counsel

Experience You Can Count On

What Sets Us Apart?

Our Philosophy
  • Love
  • Compassion
  • Integrity
  • Pursue Excellence
  • Teamwork
  • Innovative
  • Veteran Owned

The Stories That Matter

Read Our 5 Star Reviews
    He took the time to understand our goals and our family situation. He was friendly, thorough, and very knowledgeable.

    “What a great attorney! He explained everything to us in plain English, with no legal jargon. He took the time to understand our goals and our family situation. He was friendly, thorough, and very ...”

    - Mark
    Krause Donovan was wonderful...they asked all the right questions, were patient with our back and forth, and everything was wrapped up successfully.

    “My husband and I needed a will and turned to Krause Donovan for their help after the firm had invited us to a "what is estate planning all" about dinner/meeting. Having a will was something we knew we ...”

    - Kris
    Nelson was very understanding and put me at ease from the introduction. He thoroughly explained processes, answered all questions, took the time needed, and was detail-oriented.

    “I first met with Mr. Donovan this fall to discuss my estate planning. This is something a person dreads doing, but Nelson was very understanding and put me at ease from the introduction. He thoroughly ...”

    - Sherry
    They explain the process in terms that are easily understandable and always have your best interests in mind.

    “I highly recommend Kraus Donovan for all of your estate planning needs. They are thorough, knowledgeable, and very helpful. They explain the process in terms that are easily understandable and always ...”

    - Barbara
    He was able to guide us through this process with a thorough understanding of what decisions we needed to make to create clear directives for our family to follow if needed.

    “My husband and I went to Dan to help plan our estate. He and the folks at Krause Donovan were very professional, friendly, and efficient. Dan is fluent in what he practices. He was able to guide us ...”

    - Victoria
/

Take the Next Step

Schedule Your Consultation Today
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please enter your address.
  • Please enter your city.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter your zip code.
    This isn't a valid zip cide.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.